Who Are You Fighting Against?

4 July 2025

Question

I'm a parent living a quiet life in Australia, feeling torn and guilty as Israel faces crisis again. I question my role as a Jew today—I'm not on the frontlines, not donating big money, not at every rally—just folding laundry and raising kids. People say that’s enough, but is it? Am I sidelined in the story of the Jewish people? Does the Torah offer some comfort to those of us who feel irrelevant while our brothers and sisters sleep in bomb shelters and fight our wars?

Answer

There is a teaching in the Talmud: Do not fight against Hamakom.

Hamakom usually means G-d. The simple explanation of the phrase is that we should not disagree with G-d.

But literally, Hamakom means "the place". So you could read this Talmudic dictum as "Do not fight against the place you are in."

Both readings really mean the same thing. The place you are in is the exact place G-d put you. Because He knows that's where you need to be. Fighting against it is fighting G-d.

We can spend our whole lives saying, "What am I doing here? I could be doing so much more if I was over there." It may sometimes be a very noble feeling, like you said: What meaning does my bland life have here, while my cousins are on the front line there?

But in the end, it's still fighting against reality, fighting against the place you are in, and fighting against G-d. And that is never a good idea.

Don’t fight Hamakom. You are exactly where you’re meant to be, and your mission is to show up fully in that place. If you’re constantly wishing you were somewhere else, you’ll miss the sacred work right in front of you.

You have war to fight. Your children’s Jewish identity is under threat. You are on the front lines of the battle between light and darkness, between apathy and faith. And you are needed right there.

Every time you take your kids to shul, every time you light Shabbat candles and whisper a prayer for Israel, every time you kiss the mezuzah and remind your children that G-d is watching over us, you are fighting back.

You are a warrior. Not with weapons, but with words. Not rifles, but routines. Not with launchers, but with love and laundry. Your home is a shelter, not from bombs, but from the moral chaos of a confused world.

You are in the right place. You are a hero to your kids. That is all that matters.

Rabbi Moss

Sources

Rashi on Devarim 6:5, from Sifri Devarim 32:4 Beis Aharon (Karlin) Parshas Vayetze, Vayifga Bamakom