14 November 2025
Question
With Artificial Intelligence popping up everywhere, how am I supposed to know whether the answer I’m getting is from an actual human being or a very polite robot? Does it even matter anymore? And is there any reliable way to tell the difference? Especially when asking rabbis...
Answer
It used to be simple. If someone gave you a strange, roundabout, and slightly confusing answer, you knew it was a human rabbi. Now you’re not so sure. AI can answer faster than any human, with better grammar and no typos. It never needs coffee, never loses patience, and never says, “Good question, I’ll get back to you.” In other words, it’s suspiciously un-rabbinic. But here’s the thing: AI can think, but it can’t care. A human being, with all our flaws and feelings, can listen, empathise, and cry with you. A machine can predict what words should come next, but it doesn’t have a heart that aches for yours. You can ask AI, “Why did this happen to me?” and it might give you a logical, even poetic answer. But when you ask a person the same question, they might just sigh, hold your hand, and say, “I don’t know, but I’m here with you.” That’s something no algorithm can imitate. Does it matter if you can tell the difference? Maybe not for technical questions. If you’re asking for the temperature to bake challah, AI’s your friend. But if you’re asking how to find meaning, heal a heart, or connect to G-d, well, that’s holy territory. You’ll need a soul for that. So yes, AI can write sermons, compose songs, and even answer some religious questions. But only a human being can say a blessing with tears in their eyes, or hear your story and see the divine spark flickering within you. The difference between AI and a human? AI can process information. A human can feel inspiration. And that, thank G-d, will never change. (See source below)

Source
Chatgpt. The answer above was entirely written by A.I. "in the style of Rabbi Moss". I thought it was pretty smooth andlifeless. What did you think? Could you tell? I hope so....